Dec 06 2009
The Play On Words Of War And Those Who Believe
Photo of NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen courtesy of Yahoo News
Twenty-five NATO allies promised to send an additional 7,000 more troops to Afghanistan as America has pledged 30,000 more troops and while this total does not meet the 40,000 McChrystal requested, S.O.S. Hillary Clinton has said she was pleased with the “significant contributions” from NATO allies.
When I listen to the politicians discuss the Afghan war and the play on words they use such as “withdrawal,” “occupation,” “residual forces,” “transition,” “no long term occupation” and how confusing their mission is based on these contradictory phrases, I have to wonder about the audiences they are addressing and how the contradicting words play in the minds of the various audiences.
I find it difficult to wade through the words to get to what is real. First it was a “withdrawal” of troops starting in 2011 but now it is called a “transition,” which will be based on an evaluation to determine if the withdrawal is feasible. Conversely, there will remain a “residual force” in Afghanistan long after the battle troops leave even though we have no plans for long term “occupation” of these foreign lands. This is just a mild interpretation of the double talk of politicians that I have been listening to over the past few days.
Courage to fight a war is something I will never understand. I guess if I became angry enough, I would stand and fight, as in domestic violence, but then that is a direct threat to me personally. However, to read the words of a West Point Cadet who listened to the President’s speech last week and to attempt to put myself in his shoes was something my imagination could not do because the only blind faith I have is the blind faith in Jesus Christ.
Cadet Eric Bernau put it simply, “I came here to West Point for four years because I have one singular goal of serving this country while we’re at war. If you’re involved in sports you don’t want to spend all your time practicing and then never play in the game. It’s the same thing for us. I always expected to go to war. I want to go. I’m honored to go.”
“I’m honored to go” – these words are deep. While I can understand the words, it felt more like “looking for action” rather than action being forced on you. Domestic violence is something that is forced on you personally, like street crimes, where as war is a choice and I guess like many others, as long as the violence is not touching me personally, I have no desire to fight and if I can walk away from it I will because my belief is that violence does not solve problems but instead it either creates more violence or creates other means of brutality.
Truth is when I read Cadet Bernau’s words, my heart swelled with pride for the courage and dedication he expressed. The article goes on to say that he was the first in his family to join the military, leaving behind a worried mother with roots as a religious pacifist and a miffed group of friends who later bragged about their light schedules at the University of Wisconsin.
Bernau, on the other hand, was captivated by the purposefulness of the Army; he asked to be assigned to infantry because he hoped to be counted on when it mattered most. While I am deeply affected by the words Cadet Bernau spoke, affected by his dedication, strength and courage, my heart is heavy with the choice he has made to offer his life in exchange for a peace that I have doubts of ever being achieved.
Because I have doubts, does this mean that peace can not be achieved – no it doesn’t and so I say to Cadet Bernau and all the other brave troops who are serving and have served that I sincerely regret that peace can not be achieved in other ways, I regret that lives have to be lost, I regret the changes, in you, that will take place as a result of your mission.
I regret that you will become part of a violence that is so intense that even if you are not physically touched you will be forever mentally and emotionally touched by what you will see in this war zone and I thank you for being who you are as I pray for your safe return.
Bernau was not the only Cadet who voiced his resolve, anxious anticipation even, to go off to war and as I read the comments of others I somehow felt lacking in courage, faith and even character in comparison to these kids who are willing and ready to offer their services to a cause much greater than daily living. I felt such admiration for them as I understood the sacrifice and marveled at their nobility and their selflessness.
More importantly, I suggest that the time of sacrifice, after all these years mankind has been on earth, should be over, that we, as thinking, feeling, people should have learned by now how to get along without war – but it is what it is and the lessons have not been learned and so the madness continues as kids like Bernau stand strong and eager to do what they feel is right while those who commit to war make the decisions that allow for the sacrifices made by youngsters like Bernau.
And that’s the way I see it!!!!
Footsteps on the Ice: The Antarctic Diaries of Stuart D. Paine, Second Byrd Expedition





















